Validation of Plecs Results with PSCAD
14 User Manual 5SYA 2134 SEMIS – ABB Semiconductors
Figure 14 Validation results from comparison Push-pull Isolated DC-DC Converter
Figure 15 Validation results from comparison Half-Bridge Isolated DC-DC Converter
Results analysis according settings
Topology
Tester:
Date
Device used (.xml)
Limit acceptance level Green / Orange / Red
Instructions 1. Enter all values according the final results table in the column SEMIS
2. Enter all values according the final results from the PSCAD in the column PSCad
3. Verify the relative difference; Results must not vary more than 2 %
Description of Settings Set
Parameter
Absolute average difference [%] 0.12% 0.17% 0.07% 0.25% 0.16%
Max difference [%] 0.71% 2.33% 0.49% 2.35% 0.70%
Device Losses & Temperatures
Switching Losses IGBT (W) 295 295 + 0.00% 145 145 + 0.00% 244 244 + 0.00% 447 447 + 0.00% 195 196 - 0.51%
Switching Losses Diode (W) 1520 1525 - 0.33% 690 692 - 0.29% 1217 1220 - 0.25% 2535 2545 - 0.39% 959 962 - 0.31%
Conduction Losses IGBT (W) 96 96 + 0.00% 54 54 + 0.00% 54 54 + 0.00% 107 108 - 0.93% 143 144 - 0.70%
Conduction Losses Diode (W) 140 141 - 0.71% 43 44 - 2.33% 43 43 + 0.00% 255 249 + 2.35% 160 161 - 0.63%
Combined Losses IGBT (W) 390 391 - 0.26% 199 199 + 0.00% 298 298 + 0.00% 554 555 - 0.18% 339 339 + 0.00%
Combined Losses Diode (W) 1660 1666 - 0.36% 734 735 - 0.14% 1260 1263 - 0.24% 2790 2794 - 0.14% 1119 1122 - 0.27%
Junction Temperature Avg IGBT (°C)50 50 + 0.00% 45 45 + 0.00% 47 47 + 0.00% 54 54 + 0.00% 48 48 + 0.00%
Junction Temperature Avg Diode (°C) 58 58 + 0.00% 48 48 + 0.00% 54 54 + 0.00% 71 71 + 0.00% 52 52 + 0.00%
Converter Losses (W) 4100 4112 - 0.29% 1865 1869 - 0.21% 3116 3121 - 0.16% 6687 6698 - 0.16% 2916 2923 - 0.24%
Losses Efficiency 1.79 1.79 + 0.00% 1.23 1.23 + 0.00% 2.03 2.04 - 0.49% 2.89 2.89 + 0.00% 1.28 1.28 + 0.00%
DC Parameters & Control Parameters
Ouput DC Power (kW) 225 225 + 0.00% 150 150 + 0.00% 150 150 + 0.00% 225 225 + 0.00% 225 225 + 0.00%
Input DC Power (kW) 229.1 229.11 - 0.00% 151.86 151.86 + 0.00% 153.11 153.12 - 0.01% 231.68 231.69 - 0.00% 227.91 227.92 - 0.00%
Output DC Voltage (V) 750 750 + 0.00% 1000 1000 + 0.00% 1000 1000 + 0.00% 500 500 + 0.00% 750 750 + 0.00%
Input DC Voltage (V) 1500 1500 + 0.00% 1500 1500 + 0.00% 1500 1500 + 0.00% 1500 1500 + 0.00% 1000 1000 + 0.00%
Output DC Current (A) 300 300 + 0.00% 150 150 + 0.00% 150 150 + 0.00% 450 450 + 0.00% 300 300 + 0.00%
Switching Frequency (Hz) 900 900 + 0.00% 900 900 + 0.00% 1500 1500 + 0.00% 900 900 + 0.00% 900 900 + 0.00%
Duty Cycle 0.5 0.5 + 0.00% 0.66 0.66 + 0.00% 0.66 0.66 + 0.00% 0.33 0.33 + 0.00% 0.75 0.75 + 0.00%
SEMIS 24 Push-Pull Isolated DC-DC converters
Tirthasarathi Lodh, Harshavardhan Marabathina, Sravan Durga
5SNA 1600N170100, 5SDF 28L4520
Results analysis according settings
Topology
Tester:
Date
Device used (.xml)
Limit acceptance level Green / Orange / Red
Instructions 1. Enter all values according the final results table in the column SEMIS
2. Enter all values according the final results from the PSCAD in the column PSCad
3. Verify the relative difference; Results must not vary more than 2 %
Description of Settings Set
Parameter
Absolute average difference [%] 0.07% 0.26% 0.18% 0.21% 0.36%
Max difference [%] 0.43% 2.13% 0.81% 2.35% 1.25%
Device Losses & Temperatures
Switching Losses IGBT (W) 283 284 - 0.35% 163 162 + 0.61% 247 245 + 0.81% 405 406 - 0.25% 240 237 + 1.25%
Switching Losses Diode (W) 1525 1525 + 0.00% 772 774 - 0.26% 1212 1220 - 0.66% 2543 2543 + 0.00% 1221 1235 - 1.15%
Conduction Losses IGBT (W) 235 236 - 0.43% 128 128 + 0.00% 128 128 + 0.00% 274 274 + 0.00% 282 283 - 0.35%
Conduction Losses Diode (W) 140 140 + 0.00% 44 44 + 0.00% 43 43 + 0.00% 255 249 + 2.35% 148 149 - 0.68%
Combined Losses IGBT (W) 518 520 - 0.39% 291 290 + 0.34% 375 373 + 0.53% 679 680 - 0.15% 522 520 + 0.38%
Combined Losses Diode (W) 1665 1665 + 0.00% 816 818 - 0.25% 1255 1263 - 0.64% 2798 2792 + 0.21% 1369 1383 - 1.02%
Junction Temperature Before Last Switch IGBT
Junction Temperature Before Last Switch Diode
Junction Temperature Avg IGBT (°C)53 53 + 0.00% 47 46 + 2.13% 49 49 + 0.00% 57 57 + 0.00% 53 53 + 0.00%
Junction Temperature Avg Diode (°C) 58 58 + 0.00% 49 49 + 0.00% 54 54 + 0.00% 71 71 + 0.00% 55 55 + 0.00%
Converter Losses (W) 4365 4369 - 0.09% 2213 2216 - 0.14% 3260 3271 - 0.34% 6955 6943 + 0.17% 3782 3806 - 0.63%
Losses Efficiency 1.9 1.9 + 0.00% 1.45 1.46 - 0.69% 2.13 2.13 + 0.00% 3 2.99 + 0.33% 1.65 1.66 - 0.61%
DC Parameters & Control Parameters
Ouput DC Power (kW) 225 225 + 0.00% 150 150 + 0.00% 150 150 + 0.00% 225 225 + 0.00% 225 225 + 0.00%
Input DC Power (kW) 229.36 229.36 + 0.00% 152.21 152.21 + 0.00% 153.25 153.27 - 0.01% 231.95 231.9 + 0.02% 228.78 228.8 - 0.01%
Output DC Voltage (V) 750 750 + 0.00% 1000 1000 + 0.00% 1000 1000 + 0.00% 500 500 + 0.00% 750 750 + 0.00%
Input DC Voltage (V) 1500 1500 + 0.00% 1500 1500 + 0.00% 1500 1500 + 0.00% 1500 1500 + 0.00% 1250 1250 + 0.00%
Output DC Current (A) 300 300 + 0.00% 150 150 + 0.00% 150 150 + 0.00% 450 450 + 0.00% 300 300 + 0.00%
Switching Frequency (Hz) 900 900 + 0.00% 1000 1000 + 0.00% 1500 1500 + 0.00% 900 900 + 0.00% 900 900 + 0.00%
Duty Cycle 0.5 0.5 + 0.00% 0.66 0.66 + 0.00% 0.66 0.66 + 0.00% 0.33 0.33 + 0.00% 0.6 0.6 + 0.00%
SEMIS 24 Half Bridge Isolated DC-DC converters
Tirthasarathi Lodh, Harshavardhan Marabathina, Sravan Durga
5SNA 1600N170100, 5SDF 28L4520